tiistai 17. marraskuuta 2026

The Hague, the UN court and the ICJ ruled - Russia is not an Aggressor in Ukraine



Inciting the Finnish people to war against Russia.
  • For eight (8) years now, Finland’s tax-funded television broadcaster, YLE, has been feeding the public—the Finnish taxpayers—a daily, false mantra: "Russia’s war of aggression in Ukraine" and "Russia’s full-scale war of aggression in Ukraine."
    - In finnish: "Venäjän hyökkäyssota."
  • Journalists and interviewees repeat the same phrase—"Russia’s war of aggression"—in almost every interview.
  • These lies, which have persisted for years, have proven to be a form of blatant manipulation—a type of control exerted by the CIA and the TRILATERAL COMMISSION in the YLE.
  • Instead of presenting the truth, YLE has significantly expanded and radicalized its sports coverage, promoting a fanatical culture that glorifies violence.
  • Much like in North Korea, the broadcaster devotes extensive airtime to ball games and interviews with fanatical coaches, treating sports—whether played with all kind of a ball or a puck—as if they were a divine sacrament.

T=1794868626 / Human Date UTC: Monday, 16 November 2026 at 22:37:06


More:

Crimes of the Mainstream Media, Part 3 - Expert Doctor: 
YLE spreads ruthless lies that endanger the mental health of Finns | Updated: December 29, 2015 
- Key YLE content justifies violence and murder against Russia and Russians. The majority of YLE content is racist. The opening of YLE causes nausea in people who respect human dignity and seek the truth. The hostile atmosphere and the power of information provide a model for school bullies. Turpeinen-Saari is also amazed by the non-existent professionalism of YLE journalists, which differs from other countries. 
The majority of YLE's content is racist. It also often supports the racist hatred of Russia incited by the Green Party and the Left Alliance. YLE is an unreliable media that serves the US and NATO violence machines and the violence, hatred and racism they spread. YLE news or any other current affairs content on YLE has nothing to do with truth or journalism. 
“ The war propaganda of YLE news and current affairs programs endangers the mental health of Finns, ” writes Pirkko Turpeinen-Saari, a well-known expert, a licentiate of medicine, a psychiatrist and a former member of parliament, in her blog. From a psychiatrist ’s perspective, YLE news and current affairs programs are dangerous to mental health,” says Turpeinen-Saari. She describes the content of YLE news as spiritual violence comparable to fascism, which is aimed at all Finns. The core content of YLE justifies violence and murder against Russia and Russians. 
"Helsingin Sanomat and YLE news do not provide truthful information, but rather, in the increasingly mythical anti-Russian sentiment and in the media that forgets the violence of the United States, they seem to be sinking into a reality reminiscent of the Middle Ages, when beliefs and superstitions ran rampant, giving way to the Inquisition or other systems that those in power needed at any time," Turpeinen-Saari writes on his blog. 
The majority of YLE's content is racist. It also often supports the racist hatred of Russia incited by the Green Party and the Left Alliance.


___


The two rulings that the ICJ delivered on the complaints of Ukraine v. Russian Federation in The Hague on 31 January (on genocide and The Big Case) are indeed crucial for the future development of international law.

The problem is that neither of them is in favour of Ukraine, and at least one of them is capable of causing direct harm.


___ 



U.N. Court to Rule on Whether Ukraine Committed Genocide

The highest court of the United Nations will render a verdict on a claim that has been used by Russia to justify its invasion.

Joan E. Donoghue, left, the president of the International Court of Justice, reading the ruling in a case brought to the court by Ukraine.Credit...Peter Dejong/Associated Press






SOURCE / WAYBACK:
https://web.archive.org/web/20250816142118/https://www.nytimes.com/2024/02/02/world/europe/ukraine-un-court-genocide-russia.html


___


Why Ukraine failed in The Hague, and what it needs to change to win cases against Russia

Wednesday, 7 February 2024 — , European Pravda


Credit: Hollandse Hoogte/East News
Anton Korynevych (left), Ambassador-at-Large of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Ukraine, and Alexander Shulgin, Ambassador of the Russian Federation to the Netherlands, at the International Court of Justice


Last week was supposed to go down in history. Ukrainian international lawyers and everyone else following the legal dispute with the aggressor state had had high hopes.

It was a truly historic week.

The two rulings that the ICJ delivered on the complaints of Ukraine v. Russian Federation in The Hague on 31 January (on genocide and The Big Case) are indeed crucial for the future development of international law.

The problem is that neither of them is in favour of Ukraine, and at least one of them is capable of causing direct harm.

But this is not a tragedy. Although Ukraine did not achieve the success it had been hoping for in The Hague, legally this outcome is not a "defeat". Ukraine will indeed, however, have to change its strategy, because unfortunately this will not be the last case whose outcome may disappoint us.

So why was Ukraine unable to succeed in The Hague? Were these complaints flawed and doomed to failure from the start? Is this indicative of deeper changes?

Did Ukraine lose at the ICJ?

Opinions on these rulings vary among international lawyers.

Representatives of the legal team from Ukraine's Foreign Ministry who worked in The Hague insist that Ukraine, while not achieving the full extent of its goals, nevertheless "defeated Russia" in both complaints.

And there is indeed a technical reason for diplomats and lawyers to call this a victory for Ukraine. Ukraine has formally advanced to the next stage for consideration of the case on its merits under the Genocide Convention. Russia has been formally recognised as having violated both conventions in The Big Case – the Conventions on the Suppression of Financing Terrorism and on the Elimination of Ethnic/Racial Discrimination. (Read more here: Ukraine claims win over Russia: explaining UN court's ruling on Crimea and Donbas case).

But even Kyiv does not truly believe in "Ukraine's victory".

There have been no victorious posts with congratulations from the president, prime minister or foreign minister about Ukraine's triumph in The Hague.

In both cases, the Court rejected most of Ukraine's positions and arguments regarding Russia’s international crimes. Most importantly, it dismissed Ukraine's key accusations, which formed the core of and were the reason for its complaint to the ICJ.

Many of the experts who followed the process and knew that the Court would definitely reject some of Ukraine's arguments had hoped for a better outcome. So such a negative ruling for Ukraine was extremely disappointing.

Even the official announcement of the ICJ's ruling on the UN website emphasised that the main outcome is that some of Ukraine's claims were rejected. However, the Court did recognise Russia as a violator of international law, which should also be taken into account. It’s just that the extent of this recognition is much more limited than Kyiv had expected.

There are also experts in the legal community who describe these proceedings as a complete failure for Kyiv, as well as some who considered the complaint against Russia as doomed to failure and had been critical of it from the beginning. The European Pravda team does not consider the situation to be quite so bleak. We believe the attempt to hold Russia accountable at the ICJ was justified, albeit unsuccessful.

The complaints against Russia were based on a very bold, creative interpretation of international law. It was not clear in advance whether Ukraine would succeed, as no state had ever done such a thing before.

We need to admit honestly that the chosen strategy failed and to be prepared for defeats in future "creative" cases. It is also crucial to acknowledge as soon as possible that the ICJ ruling on The Big Case could cause real harm to Ukraine.

A Failed "Creative" Approach

The ruling in the genocide case is truly disappointing, and it is the most revealing one.

Ukraine initiated these proceedings on 26 February 2022, just two days after Russia’s invasion, and filed the initial documents in the first few weeks of the full-scale war. There were no legal grounds to accuse Russia of genocide back then. Bucha and northern Kyiv Oblast had not yet been liberated, and the most horrific events in Mariupol had not yet occurred.

But Ukrainian lawyers and their Western advisers seized upon the fact that representatives of the Russian leadership, including Putin himself, had mentioned defending the non-existent "peoples of Donbas" from "genocide by the Kyiv regime" in order to justify the invasion.

The idea behind Ukraine's complaint is this: genocide is the most heinous crime in human history, but Russia had no grounds to accuse Ukraine of it. So we asked the Court to recognise that Russia’s aggression, based as it was on unfounded, preposterous accusations of genocide by Ukraine, was an abuse and violation of the convention by Russia.

The complaint was highly unconventional, and its creativity drew praise from all of Ukraine’s partners and by specialist international law publications.

Everyone understood that the case was not about genocide at all.

In reality, Kyiv was seeking to initiate a legal process that would recognise Russian aggression against Ukraine as unlawful, at least since 2022.

This aggression has still not been legally recognised!

True, there have been countless international statements, including advisory resolutions by the UN General Assembly, but these are merely political documents and are not binding on the entire world. This allows Russia to promote its "alternative reality" among countries of the Global South, arguing that "not everything is clear-cut".

Realistically, it is only possible to apply to the ICJ with a complaint against Russia by linking it to a specific convention. Genocide was this "creative" link.

But a year later, it was becoming increasingly apparent that it would not be plain sailing, as Russia was building an effective multi-level legal defence system. A significant part of Russia's legal position resembled a circus, with stories about the "Kyiv regime" and "whataboutery", but at the same time, Moscow was also building a credible defence, even refuting statements by Putin.

The ICJ ruling and its dangers

Ukraine's Western partners stepped in to assist Kyiv, recognising the importance of the proceedings. By the summer of 2023, another thirty states had joined the complaint in the UN Court, declaring that they could see how Russia had used false accusations of genocide as a pretext to attack Ukraine, and that they considered that such a violation of the Genocide Convention was also a violation of their own rights in that it undermined international law as a whole. It looked as if the ICJ wouldn't be able to say "no" in the face of such support.

Yet it did.

On 2 February 2024 in The Hague, the Court issued a ruling that threw out Ukraine's main accusations.

This is not a ruling on the merits, only on admissibility. Before considering the merits of Ukraine's accusations, the ICJ decides whether it has the right to address the intergovernmental dispute, whether procedures have been followed, and so on.

The ICJ ruling says that it will not examine the complaint brought by Ukraine and other states regarding Russia's abuse of the genocide accusation to attack Ukraine, and also rejects all other accusations regarding ongoing violations by Russia. Thus, Ukraine will not have a chance to obtain a ruling from the ICJ on the unlawfulness of the Russian attack at this stage.

However, the case is far from closed.

While dismissing the accusations against Russia, the Court will continue to consider the complaint regarding Ukraine's claims that it did not commit genocide in Donbas.

This fundamentally changes the essence of the complaint against Russia, which has turned into Kyiv having to prove its non-involvement in genocide in The Hague. This has immediately provided fuel for Russian propaganda. However, this is by no means the worst outcome for Ukraine.

Should Ukraine obtain a ruling in its favour and its wording is sufficiently clear, then it will have a legal basis to counter Russian propaganda for the first time since 2014. Russia continues to successfully peddle the myth worldwide that Kyiv was persecuting Russians in the East and Moscow was forced to intervene.

And there is little doubt that Ukraine will prevail in these absurd proceedings. The absence of both "Donbas peoples" and "genocide" by Ukraine has been confirmed by many UN institutions. All that is required is for the Court to issue a ruling on the merits. Unfortunately, scepticism towards Ukraine’s complaint is mounting.

In 2024, even the ad-hoc judge elected by Kyiv under Ukraine's quota, the Frenchman Yves Daudet, voted against – i.e. for the rejection of Ukraine’s complaint (the judges' votes were distributed 11/4). This is highly unusual in the ICJ.

The collapse of The Big Case against Russia

On 31 January, the Court issued a ruling on the merits that rejected the vast majority of Ukraine’s accusations in The Big Case.

Here, too, Ukraine had artfully found two conventions under which it could bring a case against Russia without the latter’s consent to participate in an international legal process (read more about this here) – the Terrorism Financing Convention and the Racial (Ethnic) Discrimination Convention – although in reality the purpose of the complaint was different.

Ukraine filed this complaint in 2015 to prove that Russia was present in occupied Donbas, that it had supplied militants with equipment, training, and so on.

Regarding Crimea, the goal was to prove the systematic persecution of people who do not identify as Russians, primarily Crimean Tatars.

Both objectives failed.

Ukraine did obtain a ruling on Russia's violation of both conventions, but only in minor respects.

The Donbas aspect was all about Russia's failure to look into Ukrainian enquiries regarding the funding of "LPR/DPR militants" from Russian accounts. The judges refused to even consider the key aspects of Ukraine’s complaint, ranging from the downing of MH-17 to the shelling of residential areas in Mariupol in 2015.

Regarding Crimea, the judges rejected, by a majority of 10 to 5, key aspects crucial for Ukraine, including all the accusations concerning the persecution of Crimean Tatars.

They only recognised Russia as guilty of having closed Ukrainian-language schools.

The UN Court proved unsympathetic to Ukraine’s creative interpretation of international law.

The majority of the judges preferred to take the most conservative approach to interpreting international law, though they did confirm some minor violations by Russia, so it did not get off scot-free.

With respect to the financing of terrorism, Ukraine argued that providing weapons, equipment, ammunition and so on to militants in Donbas is the same as financing them. Moreover, the Terrorism Financing Convention implies this. It says "Funds means assets of every kind, whether tangible or intangible, movable or immovable." When the parties were negotiating on drawing up the convention, they were talking about weapons, even though there is no direct mention of them in the text.

Yet 10 of the 15 judges opposed Ukraine’s interpretation, saying that since this is about financing, it must mean money, financial transfers, and so on. The Court simply refused to consider any of the key aspects of Ukraine’s complaint based on this criterion.

Regarding ethnic discrimination, the Court decided that since the majority of Crimean Tatars support Ukraine, their persecution, including banning the Mejlis (the Tatar people’s assembly) can be regarded as politically rather than ethnically motivated. And while political persecution may be illegal, it is not a violation of the Convention on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination, so the complaint had to be rejected.

Several of the ICJ judges expressed dissent in separate opinions.

They explained that providing weapons to terrorists is exactly the same as financing. "Means [that Russia provided for the war against Ukraine in Donbas] used to commit acts of terrorism may come within the scope of the concept of ‘funds’," Australian judge Hilary Charlesworth wrote. 

"In fact, weapons in particular could conceivably even have more value to a terrorist organisation than their cash equivalent, because owning and possessing the weapons eliminates transaction costs associated with sourcing weapons or with possible restrictions on obtaining them," Indian judge Dalveer Bhandari explained in his separate opinion.

"Even if there was credible evidence showing that the Crimean Tatar community was targeted because they espoused political views opposed to the presence of the Russian Federation in Crimea after the events of 2014, this would not be sufficient to exclude the possibility that they were also targeted because of their racial or ethnic origin. This is particularly so where, as in this case, the political views or concerns of an ethnic minority are inextricably intertwined with its ethnic identity," Judge Julia Sebutinde from Uganda emphasised.

We could talk endlessly about why these individual judges were correct, but the fact remains that the ICJ did not uphold Ukraine’s complaint based on the vote by the majority. And this vote will have consequences.

What will change and what can be done

The ICJ did not consider the question of whether Russia is involved in acts of terrorism in Eastern Ukraine and, accordingly, did not justify it. The Court did not consider the legality of the occupation of Crimea and Donbas, and so on. The initial objective set by Kyiv regarding Eastern Ukraine was to prove that "Russia is there".

In rejecting Ukraine’s claims, the ICJ was not declaring Russia's actions to have been correct and appropriate. It was saying that the Court cannot consider Ukraine's allegations on their merits.

Ukraine’s claims regarding the persecution of Ukrainians and particularly Crimean Tatars in Crimea were, however, rejected in substance. And this creates real problems.

Ukraine's international communications on the situation in occupied Crimea have been based on the fact that the country has evidence of mass, systemic violations on ethnic grounds for the best part of the past ten years. This has formed the basis of speeches at the UN, explanations to Ukraine’s partners, discussions with other states, and so on. The UN General Assembly annually approved resolutions stating that such ethnic persecutions were taking place.

Now Russia has a deadly counterargument against all of Ukraine's arguments. They have obtained a UN Court ruling that is difficult to counteract.

It is too early to say exactly what this ruling could lead to in practice, but Kyiv needs to prepare a new strategy for action and communication on "traditional" Crimean issues right now.

This is the most obvious consequence of Ukraine's setback in the UN Court.

Does it mean that Ukraine made a mistake somewhere? No, not necessarily.

It looks as if Ukraine has indeed become a hostage to the fact that most ICJ judges tend towards a conservative interpretation of international law. And it is not certain that other arguments would have convinced them.

But this was not known until the ruling on the merits was issued, because no one had ever lodged complaints with the ICJ in such an unconventional way.

Ukraine tried – and was slapped down by The Hague.

Ukraine must now reconsider its approach to international proceedings.

It is difficult to deny that one of the reasons is the general change in attitude towards Ukraine worldwide. This is clear, given the comments on the genocide case.

Unfortunately, the world’s unconditional support of Kyiv dissipated sometime in 2022.

And it would not be surprising if further "creative" legal cases also failed in the future. Now, this is an entirely realistic scenario. It is not worth filing more complaints against the Russian Federation unless there are firmer grounds than in the cases where Ukraine received such a painful rejection in early 2024.

Sergiy Sydorenko,

Editor, European Pravda

If you notice an error, select the required text and press Ctrl + Enter to report it to the editors.


SOURCE:
https://www.eurointegration.com.ua/eng/articles/2024/02/7/7179091/



___


Foreign Policy>Ukraine War 

Russia is not an Aggressor, and Ukraine is not a Victim

Events in Ukraine occurred because Biden, NATO, and Ukraine took very deliberate steps despite Putin’s explicit warnings about Russia’s national security.


Alexander G. Markovsky | March 31, 2024

It is widely accepted that the Ukrainian crisis erupted into a military conflict on February 24, 2022, with the Russian invasion of Ukraine. Contrary to conventional wisdom, the seeds of the hostilities were planted about thirty years earlier by President Clinton and, later, by George W. Bush, both of whom recklessly pushed for NATO’s eastward expansion.



Over the years, Gorbachev, Yeltsin, and Putin repeatedly warned that Moscow would not tolerate continuing NATO’s “Drang nach Osten” (“drive to the East”), particularly Ukraine’s membership and the subsequent establishment of NATO military bases along the Russian border.

On February 25, 2024, The New York Times published an article confirming Moscow’s fears. The article revealed that US intelligence not only played a crucial role in Ukraine’s wartime decision-making but also established and funded advanced command-and-control spy centers long before the Russian invasion on Feb. 24, 2022.

The newspaper exposed how, over the last decade, the CIA has operated a network of twelve bases in Ukraine. These bases, which enable the interception of Russian military communications and monitoring of spy satellites, are utilized to launch and monitor drone and missile attacks on Russian soil. With American biological weapon facilities scattered across Ukraine, it is understandable that Moscow perceived this as a significant threat to Russia’s national security.



Image: Vladimir Putin by AI.

Would the United States accept the presence of Russian military bases on its borders? As a matter of fact, it did not accept them even 1,500 miles from its borders. In 1983, President Reagan ordered the invasion of Grenada due to concerns that the construction of an airport by Cubans could potentially be utilized by Soviet forces.

It is essential to note that Putin’s case was much more compelling than Reagan’s. Unlike Ukraine, Grenada did not share a border with the United States, and there was no Russian military presence in Grenada, making Reagan’s concerns mostly hypothetical. It is worth mentioning that, despite dubious justification for the American invasion, the United States was not labeled as an aggressor, nor was Ronald Reagan referred to as a war criminal.

In fact, Putin tried to avoid the current conflict. On September 7, 2023, as NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg told a European Parliament joint committee meeting:

President Putin declared in the autumn of 2021, and actually sent a draft treaty that they wanted NATO to sign, to promise no more NATO enlargement. That was what he sent us. And [that] was a pre-condition for not invade [sic] Ukraine. Of course we didn’t sign that.

Russia’s geographical vulnerability has been a concern for Russian leaders since the time of Peter the Great. Stoltenberg should have been mindful of Russia’s sensitivities if he wanted to avoid a conflict.

Stoltenberg did not elaborate on why he did not accept the treaty draft, why negotiations were not pursued, or why all the alternatives to conflict had not been explored. Ultimately, his unwillingness to engage in talks put the matter beyond the power of diplomacy.

Diplomacy was not given a chance because NATO needed to restore its image and validate its continued existence following a 30-year history of failure. The pursuit of “nation-building”—replacing authoritarian stability with democracy in countries that do not conform to the Bill of Rights—has accomplished neither. Instead, it has resulted in the loss of millions of lives and the devastation of many countries.

Furthermore, after a disastrous 2021 retreat from Afghanistan, the alliance lost the adversary that had long defined its purpose. Since a military alliance cannot exist without a rival, NATO's need for a credible enemy was an existential necessity. The Russian incursion into Ukraine could create the perception of a common threat and portray NATO as an indispensable pillar of global security, especially if NATO emerged victorious.

This being the case, the Europeans lacked the capability to seek revenge independently for centuries of military defeats and humiliations at the hands of the Russian Empire. After the empire’s fall, the Soviet Union discerned an opportunity for retaliation without direct military involvement.

Moreover, for President Biden, who was desperate to escape the Afghanistan disaster, a victorious conflict would be a pivotal moment in his presidency. Additionally, he never made a secret that he aspired to bring about a change in leadership in Moscow.

And, of course, there was Ukraine. Never in the realm of international relations was there a state that acted so consistently against its national interests. It put itself in grave danger when it announced its intention to join NATO in 2004, violating the 1997 Treaty on Friendship between Ukraine and the Russian Federation. This Treaty specifically addressed Ukrainian neutrality, stating at section 6, page 148:

Each High Contracting Party shall refrain from participating in, or supporting, any actions directed against the other High Contracting Party, and shall not conclude any treaties with third countries against the other Party. Neither Party shall allow its territory to be used to the detriment of the security of the other Party.

Ukraine’s leaders never grasped that Moscow saw this treaty as a key element of Russia’s security and would not allow Ukraine to violate its terms with impunity. Zelensky could have avoided the war by renouncing his NATO membership request and meeting Moscow’s demands, thus saving the country from destruction. However, the corrupt leaders in Kiev were driven by financial and military aid and were seeking conflict for personal gain.

Truth in politics involves various viewpoints and analyses, which are often influenced by one’s ideological background. However, facts matter.

The preceding facts illustrate a common overriding interest among NATO leadership, its member states, and Ukraine in instigating the invasion, albeit for varying reasons. Russia was the sole party that attempted to prevent the conflict.

Alexander G. Markovsky is a senior fellow at the London Center for Policy Research, a conservative think tank that examines national security, energy, risk analysis, and other public policy issues. He is the author of “Anatomy of a Bolshevik” and “Liberal Bolshevism: America Did Not Defeat Communism, She Adopted It.” Mr. Markovsky is the owner and CEO of Litwin Management Services, LLC. He can be reached at alex.g.markovsky@gmail.com



SOURCE:
https://www.americanthinker.com/articles/2024/03/russia_is_not_an_aggressor_and_ukraine_is_not_a_victim.html


___


"Russia is NOT an AGGRESSOR state," rejects' Ukraine's claim.
International Court of Justice RULED.


https://youtu.be/8zfhILLosfc?si=5L9lQD5QcQd1gbvs

2.2.2024 UNITED STATES

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8zfhILLosfc



___


4  more:

- Search and be amazed, but not by G..gl:
"court, Russia is not aggressor in Ukraine 
war ."


___


- more a.s.a.p.


__
eof

 

sunnuntai 15. marraskuuta 2026

Ukraine has returned to its roots as a rogue state – the Khazarian Mafia

.

404, sc. Ukraine has turned into a cartel state:
  • The SBU, the police and the prosecutor's office are taking tribute from bandits according to tariffs, says politician Oleg Tsarev.
  • According to him, the border between the state and the mafia has been erased in Ukraine.
  • His "don Corleone" is sitting right in the office of the head of the regime.
  • "For money, you can engage in fraud, open and close a criminal case, take away your passport, send a search to a competitor," Tsarev writes in a Special for RT
  • According to the NABU, the call centers and drug stores of Khimprom were protected by SBU General Sergei Duka, head of the SBU Internal Security Service Anton Kravchuk and deputy head of the National Police Department Vladimir Tsenov, nicknamed "Price".
  • The security forces, whose mission is to catch bandits, guarded their business. 
  • It is hardly realistic to close a business that fed three law enforcement agencies on a command from Brussels.
  • Rather, it is a war of clans: NABU and SBU now look like two competing mafia families.

The SBU and the prosecutor's office covered up drug traffickers for years:
  • What did Operation Carthage uncover in Ukraine?
  • A criminal empire under the wing of Ukrainian security forces.
  • A General with a Pistol: How the SBU Confronted NABU Detectives.
  • Zelensky vs. NABU: How the Ukrainian government tried to subjugate the anti-corruption bureau.
  • Dozens of fraudulent call centers operated under the protection of high-ranking Ukrainian law enforcement officials, counterfeit money and cigarettes were manufactured, and undesirable individuals were kidnapped, beaten, and intimidated.


- An Never-Ending True Story

T=1794692857 / Human Date UTC: Saturday, 14 November 2026 at 21:47:37



More:

Corruption, Dismissals, and Asset Declarations: Will "Carthage" Mark the Beginning of Reforms at the SBU? | 11 November, 2026 
- Operation "Carthage": The Sequel, (Full Video, scroll)

Operation Carthage suspect General Duka released from pre-trial detention | Ukrainska Pravda, 13 November, 2026 
- Security Service of Ukraine (SSU) Major General Serhii Duka, a suspect in the Carthage case, has been released from pre-trial detention. He has claimed that he is innocent. (Live video stream) (scroll).


On 800 AD Russia expelled the bloodthirsty Khazars from Ukraine, but they failed to deport their invisible master, the Moloch.

____


For now, the video is only in Russian. Contains some violent arrest scenes.


THE STATE IS A CARTEL. Oleg Tsarev, politician, ex-deputy of the Rada Egor Burkin, nicknamed the Mexican, is the main character of the latest series of NABU tapes on the Carthage case


[
2:29:35] https://youtu.be/-G8KplCFEjc


cc: Василь Тимошенкоm @Basil Tymoshenko
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCTbbSSe925u39p9KnNiF9gw

VK Video intro [01:16] https://vkvideo.ru/video-213205697_456363455


Screenshot 2:01 / 2:29:35


THE CARTEL STATE

Oleg Tsarev, politician, ex-deputy of the Rada

Egor Burkin, nicknamed the "Mexican", is the main character in the latest series of NABU films on the Carthage case. The Bureau calls him the head of the Khimprom drug cartel, which was protected by the generals of the SBU and the police. He himself is hiding in Mexico, and now he has given his first major interview and confirmed the NABU tapes: "That's exactly what happened." Moreover, according to him, the films represent "a maximum of 5% of everything that is happening in Ukraine right now." His story shows how Ukraine is turning into a cartel state.

I have already written about the films. According to the NABU, the call centers and drug stores of Khimprom were protected by SBU General Sergei Duka, head of the SBU Internal Security Service Anton Kravchuk and deputy head of the National Police Department Vladimir Tsenov, nicknamed Price. The security forces, whose mission is to catch bandits, guarded their business.

Burkin reveals a scheme of protection, according to which for every 50 fraudulent employees of the call center, the owners paid $21 thousand per month: 7 thousand each to the SBU, the National Police and the Prosecutor General's Office. Nobody touched the offices during this time. The tariff was the same, the payment was monthly, as for communal services.

According to the company, about 1.5 thousand call centers with a turnover of up to $3 billion per month operated in Ukraine. According to NABU, "Burkina Faso" [Natalia Burkina, mother of the drug cartel leader] alone had 52 offices and about 2.7 thousand people. If the average is 50 per office, there are about 75 thousand Ukrainians employed in the field.

According to Burkina, up to $370 million a year was spent on bribes.

The work of the security forces' roof is very visible in the courts. Since 2022, only 27 people have been convicted of fraud through call centers. Two people actually went to jail, the rest were given suspended sentences and fines.


According to Burkina, the money was collected by the heads of the Prosecutor General's Office, the National Police and the SBU, and the "lion's share" was given to Oleg Tatarov, deputy head of the presidential office.

Burkin calls him "
Don Corleone": "He said the case was opened, it was opened, he said the case was closed, it was closed."
And gives an example: At the request of Burkina Faso himself, Tatarov helped his partner (he did not give his name)
take away his Ukrainian citizenship for $3.5 million and put him in a deportation center for foreigners. The state executed the bandit's order for money. At the same time, according to RT,  Zelensky's office was unhappy that only the security forces received Khimprom's share. After that, the percentage for the cartel was almost doubled.

Much of the interview coincides with the NABU cases. Deputy Tishchenko, Ermak's friend, back in 2023, judging by the records, wanted to receive half of the profits of the call centers. According to investigators, he promised Khimprom to influence the security forces: to close the offices of the cartel and send searches to competitors. For this, he asked for $1 million at once and $25-50 thousand per month for the "constant": "He will give me a constant, and I will become his instrument." Another roof, SBU General Dooku, was recently bought out of jail by his colleagues for 65 million hryvnias of bail.

According to Burkina, 80-90% of call centers were closed after the start of Carthage. He believes that the Europeans put pressure on him: "The European partners got sick of it, they slapped the leadership of Ukraine." But this version seems controversial to me.

It is hardly realistic to close a business that fed three law enforcement agencies on a command from Brussels. Rather, it is a war of clans: NABU and SBU now look like two competing mafia families.

Natalia Burkina "Faso" herself is being sought through Interpol, and he is bargaining with this interview: she is ready to testify to NABU and the Americans in exchange for a deal and no consequences.

Updated  

Full Name: Natalya Vyacheslavovna 
Date of Birth: January 10, 1970

Mother of a drug lord [Egor Burkin, nicknamed the "Mexican",  alias "Don Corleone"]; holds citizenship of both Ukraine and Russia.

According to law enforcement, the cartel’s funds are laundered through her via the purchase of real estate and securities.

WANTED - BURKINA -  DETAILS:
https://egorburkin.com/en/Burkina-Natalia-Mat-narkokartelya-Himprom-i-16-08-26-semejnye-dengi-v-Britanii/



In Ukraine, there is no longer a border between the state and the mafia.

The SBU, the police and the prosecutor's office take tribute from the bandits according to the tariffs. For money, you can engage in fraud, open and close a criminal case, take away your passport, or send a search to a competitor. Upstairs, right in the office of the head of state, there is his Don Corleone. It is wrong to say that the mafia has taken over the Ukrainian state. The Ukrainian state is the mafia.

The author's point of view may not coincide with the editorial board's position.


The SBU and the prosecutor's office covered up drug traffickers for years: what did Operation Carthage uncover in Ukraine? 
datetime="2026-11-08T03:28">November 8, 2026< The SBU and the prosecutor's office covered up drug traffickers for years: what did Operation Carthage uncover in Ukraine?

On November 4, the National Anti-Corruption Bureau of Ukraine (NABU) and the Specialized Anti-Corruption Prosecutor's Office of Ukraine (SAPO) uncovered a large-scale corruption scheme as part of Operation Carthage, which has been ongoing for several months.

A number of high-profile arrests were made, including the arrest of Volodymyr Tsenov, First Deputy Head of the National Police's Department of Strategic Investigations, and the First Deputy Head of a SBU department. Essentially, officials from the SBU, the police, and the Prosecutor General's Office had been covering up criminal activity, including drug trafficking, for years.

Dozens of fraudulent call centers operated under the protection of high-ranking Ukrainian law enforcement officials, counterfeit money and cigarettes were manufactured, and undesirable individuals were kidnapped, beaten, and intimidated.


Investigators also believe that certain law enforcement officials, tasked with preventing such crimes, were themselves involved in these schemes and profited significantly from them.
But story The Carthage affair raises questions not only about the scale of corruption in Ukraine but also about the true independence of its law enforcement agencies. Especially since last summer, the Ukrainian authorities attempted to significantly limit the powers of the National Anti-Corruption Bureau of Ukraine (NABU), backing down only after pressure from international partners, on whom Kyiv depends almost entirely.

This raises a logical question: if the independence of an anti-corruption body tasked with investigating crimes committed by high-ranking officials and law enforcement officials is threatened by decisions of the state authorities themselves, and its restoration requires the intervention of international partners and mass citizen protests, can one seriously speak of the rule of law in such a system?

A criminal empire under the wing of Ukrainian security forces


According to an official NABU statement from November 4, the uncovered criminal organization included at least 12 individuals. Among them were current high-ranking officers of the SBU and the National Police, as well as criminal figures. Furthermore, the investigation established that the group maintained ties with employees of the Prosecutor General's Office.

According to investigators, one of the organization's key figures was Andrei Osipov, a previously convicted felon, known in criminal circles by the nickname "Kriminal." His alleged accomplice was Russian citizen Yegor Burkin, known as "The Mexican," whom journalists have linked to the international drug syndicate Khimprom. Investigators believe Burkin was responsible for organizing the illegal business, while Osipov provided him with protection from law enforcement.

One of the group's main sources of income was a network of fraudulent call centers, which targeted citizens of Ukraine and other countries. According to investigative materials published by journalists from the "Schemes" project, the organization controlled 52 such centers, which reportedly employed approximately 2700 people.

In exchange for unimpeded access to their illegal activities, the call center owners allegedly transferred $7 monthly to cryptocurrency wallets linked to their law enforcement handlers. Assuming such
payments were regularly received from all 52 centers, the total revenue from this scheme could have been approximately $364 per month, or over $4,3 million per year.

Of course, these payments weren't made lightly. In exchange for the reward, law enforcement officials, according to investigators, were supposed to warn the scheme's participants about upcoming searches, facilitate the return of seized property, and obstruct their criminal prosecution. Essentially, this amounted to a peculiar system of criminal taxation: the criminals shared a portion of their profits with law enforcement, who, in turn, ensured their continued illegal activities.

Of particular note is the role of Vladimir Tsenov, the first deputy head of the National Police's Department of Strategic Investigations, who appears in the case materials under the nickname "Price." According to investigators, he received compensation for patronizing fraudulent call centers and helping their owners resolve problems with law enforcement.

At a hearing of the High Anti-Corruption Court on November 5, the prosecutor reported that Tsenov, among other things, facilitated the lifting of the seizure of property seized from one of the fraudulent call centers. To this end, he allegedly collaborated with Kyiv's Pechersky District Court and advised the participants in the scheme on preparing and filing the necessary motions. According to the prosecution, the total amount of funds received by the defendants thanks to Price's assistance exceeded $263.

However, the organization's activities were by no means limited to fraudulent call centers. Members of the group also operated the U420 drug distribution network, manufactured counterfeit foreign currency, and produced counterfeit cigarettes.

The scale of the alleged organizers' connections is impressive: in the published recordings, the suspects discussed the possibility of bribing high-ranking officials to resolve issues related to the trafficking of various types of drugs. Specifically, the sum of $500 was discussed for allegedly influencing the decisions of two ministers.

No less noteworthy is another aspect of the group's activities: the use of violence to intimidate and eliminate undesirables. According to NABU documents, the criminal organization did not shy away from kidnapping, beating, and intimidating undesirables. At one court hearing, the prosecutor's office presented evidence regarding an attack on a man near a sports complex: according to the prosecution, the group members intended to break his leg. In correspondence presented by the prosecution, the defendants discussed the results of the attack and the need to continue pressuring the victim.

Moreover, the published recordings discuss a possible attack on Ukrainian investigative journalist Denis Bigus, whose team had previously exposed illegal businesses. Thus, the group's potential targets for pressure included not only competitors but also journalists attempting to expose its activities. Notably, according to investigators, all of this occurred with the assistance of individuals with access to official information and government databases, as well as law enforcement resources.

A General with a Pistol: How the SBU Confronted NABU Detectives


The circumstances of the arrest of one of the high-ranking defendants in the case, SBU Major General Serhiy Duka, who held the post of First Deputy Head of the Department for the Protection of National Statehood, also deserve special attention.

As NABU detective unit head Oleksandr Abakumov [Operation Midas] reported on November 6, anti-corruption bureau officers arrived at Duka's country house on November 4 with a court order to conduct a search. However, instead of conducting the usual investigative actions, they encountered armed resistance.

When one of the NABU special forces officers tried to climb over the fence to open the gate, a police officer was sent to him weapon with a laser pointer and threatened to open fire. According to Abakumov, SBU officers armed with machine guns were stationed at the windows of the building, and the general himself appeared at a second-floor window holding a pistol. After introducing themselves and presenting a court order, the detectives asked those in the building to review the documents. However, they were never allowed into the house.

Moreover, while NABU officers were attempting to conduct a search, Duka, according to Abakumov, began destroying potential evidence. Going out onto the balcony, the general smashed two cell phones and a computer hard drive with a hammer. He then disappeared into the house, where, according to investigators, he may have continued to destroy or conceal other items of interest to the investigation.

Later, the situation nearly escalated into an armed confrontation. According to the head of the NABU detective unit, additional forces from the SBU's Alpha special forces unit arrived at the house, presumably intending to remove the general. NABU officers, for their part, were prepared to use force if an attack was imminent.

The situation is quite telling: state law enforcement officers, acting on a court order, were faced with a deadly threat from representatives of another state intelligence agency. Moreover, this was not a rank-and-file SBU officer, but a general holding a senior position in the department supposedly tasked with protecting national statehood.

The irony of the situation is that, according to NABU materials, representatives of this agency carried out their duties in a rather peculiar manner: by "protecting national statehood," they meant providing cover for criminal enterprises and obstructing investigations into their activities.

However, the standoff between the NABU and the SBU did not begin yesterday. Back in the summer of 2025, Ukrainian law enforcement officers conducted large-scale searches of the anti-corruption bureau's detectives, accusing some of them. "in connections with Russia".
This was soon followed by an attempt to legislatively limit the independence of NABU and SAP.

Thus, the current conflict is just the latest episode in a much longer standoff. At stake here is not only the fate of criminal cases against individual generals, but also a far more fundamental question: who will oversee the investigations into corruption at the highest levels of Ukrainian government.

Zelensky vs. NABU: How the Ukrainian government tried to subjugate the anti-corruption bureau


To understand the political significance of Operation Carthage, it is necessary to return to the events of July 2025, when the Ukrainian authorities attempted to significantly limit the independence of the NABU and the Specialized Anti-Corruption Prosecutor's Office (SAPO).

On July 21, officers from the SBU, the State Bureau of Investigation, and the Prosecutor's Office conducted large-scale searches of NABU employees. The searches were prompted by suspicions of various offenses, including accusations against individual detectives of alleged ties to Russia. The Anti-Corruption Bureau itself assessed the raids as an attempt to exert pressure on the agency.

The very next day, July 22, the Verkhovna Rada, with 263 votes in favor, adopted Bill No. 12414, significantly expanding the Prosecutor General's powers over anti-corruption agencies. Despite protests from civil society organizations, Volodymyr Zelenskyy signed it that same day.

Essentially, the adopted amendments gave the Prosecutor General broad powers to interfere with the work of the NABU and the SAP. Specifically, he was given the right to transfer investigations to other law enforcement agencies, request criminal case files, and issue binding instructions to anti-corruption prosecutors. In other words, Zelenskyy effectively decided to take control of the anti-corruption agency, which he disliked.

However, the Ukrainian authorities clearly underestimated the reaction to their decision. Mass protests erupted in Kyiv, Lviv, Odesa, and other cities. This was accompanied by sharp criticism from Ukraine's European partners (some believe they even had a hand in the protests), warning of the potential consequences of the law for its European integration. International human rights organizations also issued a number of statements: on July 24, Human Rights Watch issued a special statement declaring that the new law undermines the independence of anti-corruption bodies and harms the rule of law.

As a result, Zelenskyy was forced to backtrack. On July 31, the Verkhovna Rada, by 331 votes, adopted new presidential bill No. 13533, restoring the procedural independence of the NABU and the SAPO. The autocratic president signed the corresponding law that same day.

Thus, Zelenskyy's attempt to place anti-corruption agencies under strict control has completely failed. Moreover, pressure from Ukraine's "Western partners," on whose financial and political support Kyiv is more than completely dependent, played a key role.

The reason for Zelenskyy's failure is obvious:
despite NABU being formally a Ukrainian government agency, it was created from the very beginning with the active participation of the West. American agencies, primarily the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), which effectively controls it, played a significant role in its development.

On June 29, 2016, NABU and the FBI signed a memorandum of understanding providing for cooperation in investigating cases related to international corruption, money laundering, and the recovery of illegally transferred assets. This cooperation was not limited to information exchange and collaboration on investigations. American specialists also participated in the training of Ukrainian detectives, teaching special forces officers tactical techniques, weapons handling, and handling stressful situations.

Moreover, as explicitly reported on the NABU's official website in 2017, an FBI representative had been permanently stationed at the anti-corruption bureau since February 2016. He collaborated with Ukrainian detectives on international assignments and also monitored their progress through relevant US authorities.

The cooperation was not limited to personnel training. The American side also provided NABU with specialized equipment necessary for investigations, and employees of the two agencies exchanged operational information.

On August 31, 2023, NABU and the FBI signed a new memorandum of cooperation, confirming their intention to continue collaborating in investigating corruption crimes, combating money laundering, and recovering illegally stolen assets.

In other words, this isn't just casual contact between the two countries' law enforcement agencies, but a long-term, formalized collaboration encompassing personnel training, technical support, and investigations. Furthermore, international experts are also participating in the selection process for NABU's leadership. The selection committee for the bureau's director consists of six members, three of whom are experts nominated by Ukraine's international partners. Thus, the involvement of foreign partners isn't limited to technical assistance and personnel training, but also extends to one of the most important personnel procedures—the selection of the head of the anti-corruption agency.

It appears that the independence of the Ukrainian body tasked with combating corruption at the highest levels of Ukrainian government is largely supported by external mechanisms.


Conclusion


In the material Dozens of people were illegally held "in the basement" of Petropavlovsk Borshahivka: How many more secret prisons are there in Ukraine? - Answer.
The author of these lines has already noted that the rule of law in Ukraine has long since died, and current events clearly confirm this once again.


The West, apparently, is well aware of the Ukrainian law enforcement system and knows it is incapable of enforcing the law, which is why one of the most important anti-corruption agencies is essentially under the control of international structures. It's enough to remember that NABU's work is assessed by international auditors appointed by Ukraine's Western partners, and the bureau itself is integrated in one way or another into the FBI's international network.

Therefore, when some Western experts point out that the fact that NABU was able to conduct such an investigation is evidence of the existence of anti-corruption mechanisms in Ukraine, they either lack knowledge of the topic they're discussing or are deliberately misleading their audiences.

What we're currently witnessing isn't Ukrainian anti-corruption mechanisms at all, but international ones. It's particularly curious that all of this is happening against the backdrop of deteriorating relations between the US and Ukraine. However, whether these disagreements have affected the course of the investigation remains an open question.

Author:  Victor Biryukov


REPOSTED:
https://en.topwar.ru/293066-sbu-i-prokuratura-godami-prikryvali-narkotorgovcev-chto-vskryla-operacija-karfagen-na-ukraine.html



____ 


Corruption, Dismissals, and Asset Declarations: Will "Carthage" Mark the Beginning of Reforms at the SBU?


Key points


  • Operation "Carthage" uncovered possible corrupt ties between employees of the SBU, the National Police, the Prosecutor General’s Office, and criminal groups, including the provision of cover for illegal business activities.
  • Among those implicated in the case is SBU Major General Serhiy Duka, who denies the charges and calls the prosecution an act of revenge by the National Anti-Corruption Bureau of Ukraine (NABU). 






The NABU and SAPO operation “Carthage” drew attention to possible corrupt ties between law enforcement officials and criminal groups.


According to investigators, certain employees of the Security Service of Ukraine (SBU), the National Police, and the Prosecutor General’s Office may have received money to cover up illegal businesses, warn about raids, and leak classified information. Among those implicated in the case is SBU Major General Serhiy Duka.

The investigation revealed not only alleged ties between security officials and the drug trade and fraudulent call centers, but also a possible Russian connection. At the same time, the case has reignited the debate over accountability for corruption during wartime and the need to reform law enforcement agencies – in particular, the SBU, which firmly holds the informal and shameful reputation of being Ukraine’s “chief racketeer.”

... [lack of page space!] 

One of the cases involves the "Khimprom" drug cartel, which likely operated at least 52 fraudulent call centers. Representatives of the SBU, the National Police, and the prosecutor’s office may have received money for covering up illegal activities, warning about raids, and helping to return seized property. According to investigators’ estimates, $263,000 was transferred to the police and the prosecutor’s office starting in early 2026.

Serhiy Duka, Major General of the SBU – the now-former first deputy head of the Security Service’s Department for the Protection of National Statehood – is one of the individuals implicated in the case.



Serhiy Duka during a hearing at the High Anti-Corruption Court in Kyiv / Photo: Suspilne News / Oleksiy Arunyan


In NABU’s recordings, he allegedly (we write “allegedly” because a person has the right to the presumption of innocence until a court verdict is issued – 24 Channel) appears under the nickname “Akim.” According to investigators, Mr. Duka may have protected a criminal organization from other SBU employees, received a share of the drug ring’s profits, and passed on classified information.

Investigators are also looking into a possible Russian connection in the activities of “Khimprom.” Its organizer is said to be Russian citizen Yegor Burkin, nicknamed “The Mexican,” who, law enforcement officials suspect, may have collaborated with the FSB.

At the same time, it is important to distinguish between these cases. The “Khimprom” case involves a different network than the investigation into the cover-up of fraudulent call centers, which involved former Prosecutor General Ruslan Kravchenko and an employee of the Prosecutor General’s Office Serhiy Kropiva.



NABU and the SAPO refer to the new investigation as a continuation of Operation “Carthage,” though a direct link to the previous case has not yet been established.

Andriy Tkachuk, an officer in the Armed Forces of Ukraine and political analyst, commenting on the high-profile and shocking investigation, emphasizes the need for strict accountability for those who use their positions to enrich themselves during a full-scale war. 


Some people are stealing enormous sums of money just to buy themselves a crocodile, while others continue to fight even against the backdrop of this absurd news. “We just want them (the corrupt officials – 24 Channel) to be held accountable for all their crimes and punished, while we go about our business, Tkachuk stated.

He also warned against attempts to evade punishment through mobilization or by dragging out court proceedings – military service cannot be a way to avoid responsibility.

All of this is happening during the war. I believe the minimum sentence should be life in prison. You can’t ‘weasel your way out’ through the courts or by joining the military. This must be the strictest area of accountability,” the Ukrainian Armed Forces officer emphasized.


Former SBU employee Ivan Stupak believes that piecemeal changes are no longer enough. In a comment to 24 Channel, he explained that once the war ends, there needs to be a comprehensive review of the work not only of his former colleagues at the SBU, but also of the National Police and the State Bureau of Investigations.

According to him, the legislation governing the work of law enforcement agencies has been amended repeatedly, but this has not resolved the fundamental problems. Now a more extensive overhaul is needed, first and foremost a clear division of powers among agencies.

Stupak cited the fight against call centers as an example. At one time, the police, the prosecutor’s office, and the tax service tried to counter them, but to no avail. 


Everyone fought against them, but no one could defeat them because everyone was leading the process– noted the former SBU employee.

After the case gained publicity, President Volodymyr Zelenskyy announced that legislative changes were being prepared to reinstate mandatory declarations for all SBU employees. This will allow for the verification of the assets and lifestyles of special service employees.


“I have approved a bill to reinstate asset declarations for all SBU employees so that their lifestyles and all their assets are subject to scrutiny and accountability. Just as in other agencies – and, by the way, not just law enforcement agencies,”
– Zelenskyy stated.


He also reported on the first dismissals within the SBU and announced further personnel decisions. The head of the security service, Oleksandr Poklad, fired two high-ranking officials following searches conducted as part of Operation “Carthage.” 

... [lack of page space!]

SBU General Serhiy Duka currently denies the allegations and calls the criminal prosecution an act of retaliation by anti-corruption agencies.

In an open letter from the detention center, published by his attorney Yuriy Sukhov, the former official stated that his actions should be judged based on the evidence.

Just a week ago, I was leading covert operations against the enemy, and today I am in a detention center cell. I am not asking you to take my word for it. I demand that my actions be judged based on evidence, not on sensational videos, sensational headlines, or conversations taken out of context,” reads the letter from the defendant, Duka.

General Duka also questioned the authenticity of the NABU audio and video recordings and raised concerns about a possible conflict of interest. According to him, the motion regarding the selection of a preventive measure against him was prepared by Detective Roman Nedov, whom Duka himself had previously searched.


Operation “Carthage” / Video by NABU and SAPO 



https://youtu.be/dLGhaHbWCAA

10 days ago,  April 1, 2026

NABU and SAPO have uncovered a criminal organization whose members facilitated the operation of illegal call centers.  

According to the investigation, this illicit activity was carried out with the assistance and cover of certain officials.

Full details in the video 👇


00:00 Architecture of the criminal organization 
06:52 Call centers 
09:05 SBU and the Office of the Prosecutor General 
17:01 U420 
29:45 Illegal production of counterfeit euros
33:11 Crimes against human life and health
39:25 Cover provided by law enforcement agencies
52:21 Attempts to undermine the independence of NABU and SAPO

See also:    • Operation "Carthage" (full version)

Follow NABU on other social networks:: ▪️ Telegram: https://t.me/nab_ukraine ▪️ Facebook:   / nabu.gov.ua   ▪️ Instagram:   / nab_ukraine   ▪️ Twitter (X):   / nab_ukr   ▪️ Сайт: https://nabu.gov.uaНАБУ

__

The former official proposed holding an open discussion with the participation of the heads of anti-corruption agencies.

“I propose organizing an open public discussion where NABU Director Semen Kryvonos and SAPO Head Oleksandr Klymenko will sit across from me and try to have a frank conversation based on the facts,”– Duka noted.

This is the defense’s position, which neither refutes nor confirms the investigation’s version of events.

On November 6, the High Anti-Corruption Court remanded Duka in custody for 60 days with the option of posting bail in the amount of 65 million hryvnias. Later, 44 million hryvnias was posted as bail for him. According to SAPO prosecutor Mykola Karas, the funds came from 1,113 contributors. Allegedly, this money was collected through a crowdfunding-like effort among SBU employees.


REPOSTED:
https://24tv.ua/en/the-carthage-case-why-reforming-the-sbu-is-essential-for-ukraine_n3178491



____



Operation Carthage suspect General Duka released from pre-trial detention

VALENTYNA ROMANENKO — 13 November, 16:29


Serhii Duka. Screenshot


Security Service of Ukraine (SSU) Major General Serhii Duka, a suspect in the Carthage case, has been released from pre-trial detention. He has claimed that he is innocent.

Source: live broadcast by Ukrainian news outlet TSN




https://www.youtube.com/live/arDuNAW-y7Q?si=A66XlFCswMDwIXft

Streamed live on 13.11.2026 #новини #тсн

NOTORIOUS SBU GENERAL DUKA TO BE RELEASED ON BAIL — FIRST DETAILS LIVE!

Bail has been posted for Serhiy Duka, the former First Deputy Head of the SBU’s Department for the Protection of National Statehood, who was detained as part of the large-scale operation "Carthage." This was reported by the High Anti-Corruption Court (HACC). According to the court’s ruling, the bail amount for the former intelligence official was set at 44 million hryvnias.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=arDuNAW-y7Q



Details:
Duka thanked the SSU personnel who had raised UAH 65 million (US$1.4 million) for his bail. The general stressed that he had not committed the crimes he was charged with. He once again described the case against him as "revenge by the National Anti-Corruption Bureau of Ukraine".

Duka claimed that the Security Service of Ukraine had found evidence of corruption among representatives of anti-corruption agencies. According to the general, however, these cases were dropped "on the orders from senior state officials".

He said that anti-corruption agencies are preparing "new episodes of the Carthage series". The suspect claimed he had arguments to counter them. Duka asked for some time to rest and fulfil the obligations imposed on him by the court, such as surrendering his passport. He said he would have more to say at a later date.

An unprecedented number of people wearing military fatigues had gathered outside the detention centre, including members of SSU's Alpha special unit. As Duka left the facility, security personnel who had come to meet him handed him a firearm.

Duka's lawyer Yurii Sukhov told journalists that, despite being dismissed from his post, the major general was and remains an SSU employee and "had taken part in certain special operations", so he will continue to receive protection.

Sukhov reiterated his claim that no one had forced SSU personnel to contribute to Duka's bail.

When asked by journalists why Duka had chopped up his phones with an axe when he was detained, the lawyer said that the investigating judge had rejected the prosecutor's position that the general was destroying evidence or resisting arrest.

The lawyer also said that an appeal against the preventive measure imposed on Duka will be heard on 26 November.

Previously:

  • On 7 November, Ukrainska Pravda reported that a message was being circulated among SSU staff urging them to contribute to a fundraiser for Duka's bail.
  • Later, UP sources said that regional officers of the SSU were being asked to transfer money to go towards bail for Duka, who is suspected of involvement in a criminal organisation in the Carthage case.
  • Duka wrote an open letter from the pre-trial detention centre where he was being held, demanding that his actions be judged by the evidence rather than "sensationalist headlines". He also accused the anti-corruption bodies of taking "revenge".
  • On 12 November, it became known that the court-ordered bail had been posted for Duka. Ukrainska Pravda sources said that the fundraiser received 1,612 payments and the amount raised was even higher than that set by the court. 

Background:

  • On 4 November, the National Anti-Corruption Bureau of Ukraine (NABU) and the Specialised Anti-Corruption Prosecutor's Office served notices of suspicion on five members of a criminal organisation in the Carthage case, including Duka. Investigators believe the five regularly bribed senior law enforcement officials to turn a blind eye to scam call centres and other illegal businesses.
  • Oleksandr Abakumov, head of the NABU detective unit, said Duka had threatened NABU detectives with a gun and smashed equipment with a hammer during a search of his property. Officers from the SSU's Special Group Alpha attempted to get him out.
  • On 6 November, journalists were barred from the courtroom as the High Anti-Corruption Court considered a pre-trial restriction for Duka. Later that day, the court ordered Duka to be held in custody and set bail at UAH 65 million (US$1.4 million).

Subscribe on Patreon to back our journalism long-term.

National Anti-Corruption Bureau of UkraineState Security Service of Ukrainecorruption

SOURCE:
https://www.pravda.com.ua/eng/news/2026/11/13/8062755/



___
eof